Let's Settle the Lube Debate! 

When it comes to getting down and dirty, few things are as underrated and misunderstood as lube. Even if you’re solo, coupled up or somewhere in between, the right lube can take your pleasure play from nothing to superb. But there’s one slippery debate that still leaves people scratching their heads: silicone lube or water-based.

So, if you’ve ever wondered what lube is, is water based lube better, or even thought: ‘can I just use water?’ (please don’t) Get ready, we are going into almost everything and anything in the world of lubes. 


So, What Is Lube Anyway?

Lube (short for lubricant) is a gel, liquid or oil that reduces friction and makes everything glide smoothly. It’s not only for those experiencing dryness, but it’s also for everyone who wants a more pleasurable, comfortable and safe experience. So, if you’re spicing up your sex life, experimenting with sex toys or even using it for medical reasons, lube is your must-have best friend.


Silicone Lube vs Water Based: What’s the Difference?

Water-based lube is the crowd-pleaser. It’s light, easy to wash off and compatible with almost everything. It’s made mostly with water and a few safe additives for that slippery texture.

On the other hand, silicone-based lube is the long runner of the lube world. It’s silky smooth, durable and famously resistant to drying out. This means no mid-action reapplication is needed.


The Pros and Cons Showdown

Not all lubes are created equal. Here’s the friction-free truth.


Lube Made of Water

Strengths:

  • Doesn’t harm sex toys (the safest option for silicone toys)

  • Safe for all types of condoms 

  • Easy to clean up with water

  • Feels light and natural

Weaknesses:

  • Dries more quickly than silicone

  • May require reapplication during extended sessions

  • Not suitable for use in water 


Lube Made of Silicone

Strengths:

  • It lasts longer than water-based lube

  • Amazing for anal play and extended sessions

  • Waterproof, so it works in water

  • Rated as the best lube for intense play

Weakness:

  • Can damage silicone toys 

  • More difficult to remove. Water and soap are required

  • More expensive than water-based lube


Is Water-Based Lube Better for You?

Your needs will determine the answer.

For those seeking a lubricant that is lightweight, toy-friendly, and easy to clean, water-based lube is a fantastic choice. It’s even more ideal for folks who are sensitive to additives or want something uncomplicated.

That said, if your goal is no interruptions and max endurance, silicone is your mate. For prolonged use, anal play or underwater enjoyment, this is the best silicone lube choice if you want persistent slipperiness. 


So, Why is Silicone Lube so Popular?

Preservatives and sugar-like ingredients like glycerin, which are found in many water-based formulations, are absent from silicone.

That means fewer ingredients to mess with your natural balance and way less risk of dryness, irritation or those ‘why does it burn?’ moments. Because it doesn’t absorb into the skin or evaporate. Silicone lube glides on (and on…and on), which makes it a top pick for people with sensitivities or anyone who doesn’t want to reapply mid-play. 

It’s also a shower necessity because it's waterproof, but be careful with your footing! The best silicone lube is well worth the investment if you want comfort, consistency and a little extravagance in the bedroom.


Can I Use Water as Lube?

In theory? Sure. In practice? No.

While water may appear to be a natural option, it evaporates rapidly, raises friction and can lead to irritation or micro tears in the skin. Not only is it uncomfortable but it also ups your risk of infections. Therefore, just because it’s wet doesn’t mean it’s right.


Does Water-Based Lube Cause Yeast Infections?

Not inherently but here’s the tea.

Certain water-based lubes contain sugars or glycerin, which may disrupt the vaginal flora and cause yeast infections in those who are susceptible. Choose glycerin-free or pH-balanced water-based lubricants if you're prone to them. Although silicone lubes are less likely to feed bacteria, it’s best to carefully read your product labels for any warnings about irritants.


Which One Wins? Silicone vs Water Based Lube?

The short answer: You win when you choose the lube that works best for your body and needs.

  • For short sessions or daily use with toys, use a water-based lubricant.

  • For long sessions, anal or shower play, go with a silicone-based lube.

  • For sensitive folks, always look for organic and hypoallergenic options in either category.


Lastly, Don’t Skip Lubing 

Our experts at Wild Fantasy state that there isn’t a ‘this is good’ or ‘that is bad’ solution in the silicone lube vs water based debate. What turns you on, how you like to play and what your body reacts to best will determine the best option.

But always remember, using lube isn’t a sign of ‘not enough’. It’s a sign you know how to do it right.

So even if you’re going lone ranger fun or warming up with a partner, lube up and let the good times roll.

If you’re new to lubes, check out our Beginner’s Guide to Lubricants for more juicy details. You can also browse our full range of water-based lubes and silicone-based lubricants to see if anything catches your eye.